Tags
Australia, Food & Drug Administration, hip, Hip Replacement, Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, Knee, knee replacement, UNited States
Hip and Knee Implants: Old Ones May Be Better Than New Ones « AARP.
Hip and Knee Implants: Old Ones May Be Better Than New Ones
Posted on 12/27/2011 by Candy Sagon
When it comes to artificial hip and knee joints, new doesn’t necessarily trump old.
A five-year Australian study has found that the newer hip and knee replacement joints, including the metal-on-metal hip implants, are performing no better than the older, less expensive devices that used plastic.
In fact, 30 percent of the new joints are performing worse than the older versions, researchers found.
The study, published in the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, looked at Australian patient data on new hip and knee implants from 2003 to 2007, comparing their performance rate to that of three best-performing older devices.
The study’s findings are striking: None of the new joint implants performed any better than older versions.
While about 70 percent of the newer ones performed equally well, 30 percent of the newer hip implants and 29 percent of newer knee joints did worse, the study found, requiring patients to have repeat surgery.
The study’s results has implications for the U.S., where 700,000 Americans undergo hip or knee replacement annually. That number is expected to rise as the population ages.
The Australian researchers concluded that the new devices were not only potentially detrimental to patients, they also were contributing to increased health care costs.
The problem, the researchers wrote, is that many new artificial hip and knee joints are being introduced with “limited or no clinical evidence to justify their use.” Insufficient testing of new devices also makes it difficult for surgeons to compare their performance with established devices with longer track records.
Other studies have also questioned the benefits of newer hip joints.
Just this past November, a study of hip implants commissioned by the FDA found that new versions, including all-metal and all-ceramic implants, were no better than the older ones that used metal or ceramic with plastic.
Photo credit: triblocal.com
Related articles
- Hip and Knee Implants: Old Ones May Be Better Than New Ones (aarp.org)
- New Models of Hip and Knee Implants Not Better, Study Finds – NYTimes.com (earlsview.com)
- Financial toll soars for hip implant failures – KansasCity.com (earlsview.com)
- Zimmer knee replacement manufacturer sued for metal on metal design | Louisiana Record (earlsview.com)
- Will Flawed All-Metal Hip Replacements Cost J&J and Zimmer $5 Billion? (forbes.com)
- UK surgeon warns public about dangers of all-metal hip implants, especially for women | Depuy Hip Recall (earlsview.com)
- New discovery could lead to better artificial hips (gizmag.com)
- Nancy’s Journey – chronicling her journey through hip replacement surgery and recovery (earlsview.com)
- MD News – Engineering High-Quality Specialty Care: The Joint Replacement Program at Bronx-Lebanon Hospital Center (earlsview.com)
- New report highlights metal hip implant problems | Reuters (earlsview.com)
I am a Clinical Psychologist in San Francisco. My specialty is counseling and psychotherapy with orthopaedic patients. There are often problems in living after orthopaedic surgery and there can be emotional issues like sadness, trauma and
nervousness. If you are suffering from such issues and are in or around San Francisco, please feel free to call for an appointment.
Thanks Dororthea – I fully agree. Just walking some days is a real struggle and for a 53 year old that is a major problem! Getting your motivation and confidence back after major surgery and the pain meds is a major. If you feel like contributing any material to the blog I would be pleased to publish it with your contact details.
Regards
Earl
Pingback: Will Flawed All-Metal Hip Replacements Cost J&J and Zimmer $5 Billion? – Forbes « Earl's View
Pingback: Hip implant lawsuits pile up – Canada – CBC News « Earl's View
Pingback: Novel – Dual Pivot Hip | Hip Replacement, Total Hip Replacement | Total Joint Joint « Earl's View
Pingback: Metal-on-Metal Hip Implants > Concerns about Metal-on-Metal Hip Implant Systems « Earl's View
Pingback: Isn’t this typical! Knee Implant patient says he was ‘left to suffer’ – Hamilton Advertiser « Earl's View
Pingback: Health News – New blood to improve life of artificial joints « Earl's View