Tags
Bone fracture, brisbane qld australia, femur, Health, hip, Hip Replacement, Medicine, metallosis, Necrosis, Osteotomy, recliner chair, surgery
Here We Go Again
Stuart Cain, Brisbane, QLD, Australia
I have had a lot of time recently to ponder the last couple of years and the more I think about it what has happened to me and the many thousands of others out there, especially readers of this blog, is something that defies belief. I have included a photo that my wife took of me (unbeknown to me at the time), of me sleeping in the recliner chair where I have spent the best part of the last year as I find it too uncomfortable to sleep in our bed. This may not seem like too big a deal, but as a 43 year old married father and grandfather, not being able to be able to even sleep next to my wife is something I find very difficult to stomach (let alone being able to actually maintain a ‘normal’ physical relationship)! I used to joke at the start of this that this was ‘the chair of knowledge’ as I used to spend all of my time researching, reading and talking to people on the phone or internet, to collect as much information and knowledge of the experiences of others, so that whenever I spoke to anyone I had as much information at my disposal as humanly possible.
I have now come to the point where I resent even having to sit in the chair, let alone sleep in it! I am sure that there are many of you out there that will relate to this, and remember, this is all because we were ‘foolish’ enough to trust a doctor, a medical prosthetics manufacturer and distributor or whatever other advice we each received before we decided to have a MOM implant (no matter who made it) put into our bodies! So as I sit here in my chair, I wanted to share some thoughts, hopefully provoke some ideas for each of you to take on as your own and above all else encourage each and every one of you to remember that you aren’t going through any of this on your own and that we are all out there willing to listen and advise where appropriate.
Remember it is not weak to share your pain, whilst we cannot take it on physically, we can empathise with you and maybe even help you to get through it! I hope the other photo I have included doesn’t upset anyone but I wanted to share a visual reminder of what this is doing to each and every one of us (my apologies in advance if this does indeed upset anyone).
This is a picture taken during my second revision, for those who haven’t read my previous story I had my first revision in November 2010, in late September 2011 I stood up from a chair at home and snapped the titanium stem in my femur clean in half without breaking the bone. This photo was taken by the surgeon during the second revision. The reason my stem snapped was because the metallosis in my femur had killed off or necrosed the bone and this allowed the stem to ‘flex’ as it hadn’t adhered to the bone as it was intended to do. The silvery, shiny section within my femur is the ‘evidence’ of metallosis, this was the point at which my stem snapped, I subsequently had an Osteotomy (splitting of the bone) for the surgeon to be able to retrieve the bottom portion of the stem.
You might also note that there are a number of ‘dark’ patches within the cross cut bone below (toward the knee) the point of the metallosis. These are evidence of metallosis actually within the bone itself, these do not show up on imaging and can only be discovered by ‘slicing’ into the bone. I have no doubt that many of you out there are actually suffering from the same issue (not that I recommend you race out and have an operation!), but I want you to be aware of the existence of these things and the reality that none of us know for sure exactly how our bodies have been affected by the poison that Cobalt and Chrommium become once introduced to the human body. The one thing that this photo does not show (as it had already been removed at this point), was that even after less than 12 months of having the original revision, the surgeon discovered more necrotic (dead) tissue around my whole hip joint, this was in muscle and other tissues directly attached to the hip.
I would also point out that luckily for me, this revised joint was NOT a MOM implant, so if this is occurring even after the MOM implant is removed, I fear that many of you out there may be experiencing the same issues. Again I am not suggesting that you all need to go out and have more surgery, but I do implore you to be vigilant with your own health, ask questions if you have concerns and above all else, if you aren’t happy with the answers, seek a second opinion. This brings me to my next bit of evidence for you all to consider.
After the operation in the picture (Sept 2011), I continued to have a great deal of pain and great difficulty walking or mobilising, I couldn’t sleep in my own bed and took to the recliner chair, and as I have developed a rare form of anaemia thanks to Cobalt poisoning, I continued to bleed internally and with regular blood tests was not recovering my haemoglobin (red blood cell) levels. I had follow up imaging that was suggesting that not only was my ‘Osteotomy’ fracture not healing, but as I had a very large/long stem inserted to try to ‘stabilise’ my hip joint I appeared to be ‘developing’ fractures running down my femur toward my knee.
By February 2012 I had become very frustrated and the recent x-rays that I had done suggested a worsening of the fractures. This was accompanied by ever-increasing pain, even more difficulty mobilising and walking and a constant swelling in my thigh. It was time for a second opinion. I was able to get this arranged quite easily and my new surgeon confirmed that he indeed thought I had active fractures developing below my stem and that I would require more surgery and he ordered a Nuclear Bone Scan which confirmed the diagnosis.
I gave my previous surgeon a chance to review my x-rays (which my new doctor had picked up and immediately identified the fractures), however I didn’t mention the Bone Scan which in hindsight may have been unfair. He refused to concede that there were any fractures and suggested I have some Cortisone injections into my thigh to ‘relieve’ the pain and swelling. My decision to seek a second opinion as far as I was concerned had been vindicated and I consequently had my 3rd revision in March this year which also included major grafting within the femur and a ‘rebuilding’ of the top of my femur with meshing to facilitate the placement of the new implant. In this instance the surgeon found (unhappily I don’t believe he had photographed it) more evidence within the bone and around the hip joint of metallosis induced necrotic tissue. Remember this is now 18 months since my MOM implant was removed.
I am now going in again in 2 weeks’ time, the fracture that was ‘caused’ by my Osteotomy has now not healed in 12 months and my hip joint needs to be ‘checked’ for loosening as the fracture has caused a piece of bone to become ‘detached’ from the graft done in March.
The current plans for this operation already involve a plate being somehow attached (I say this as the surgeon has genuine concerns that I don’t have the bone density to cope with screws), more grafting to try to ‘plug the fracture’ and any other ‘gaps’ that need to be filled and hopefully I won’t need another revision, but this is an option if I have done any inadvertent damage to my current prosthesis through ‘adapting’ to the current fracture issues.
The point I want to make here is that my surgeon has made me aware that there is about to be published evidence that Cobalt ions have an adverse effect on bone fracture or breaks healing (I promise as soon as I get this article I will post it unless anyone beats me to the punch). He has genuine fears that given my recent record with this (Cobalt induced metallosis), that when he does go in he will find more metallosis and the worst case scenario will be that too big a portion of the bone is affected in this way and then we will have a lot less options to try to repair this. If there are large sections that have already necrosed (as this doesn’t show up on regular imaging), we may have to consider the viability of a repair, this is certainly a place I don’t want to go to, however the surgeon has rightfully warned me that this could be a possibility and I respect his integrity in doing this.
So here we are today, stuck in a chair, counting down the days to the next surgery and hoping for a good outcome, however I would be lying to you all if I said I was confident! For the first time in a few surgeries now, I have an instinctual feeling of concern bordering on dread, now I am not usually a negative person, however I can’t escape my own doubts this time and I will just have to learn to deal with this! Now after all of that,
I want to dedicate my next thoughts to Earl, Howard, Bob, Brooks, Meg and the many other wonderful people I have met throughout my entire experience as a ‘hip patient’ (that used to actually sound cool!).
I want to encourage all of you who read this, your loved ones or those that you confide in to please take this on-board. None of us are ever alone! Whilst I and many others are fortunate to have loved ones around us, if you don’t have direct support, please remember that we are always here! You may not know us, or even feel like we will understand, but you can trust us because of all the people in the world we will have an insight into what you are going through.
I always used to teach my nurses to never use statements like “I know how you feel”, especially when talking to patients or their loved ones! But we will have an insight into what you may be experiencing because most of us or our loved ones have been through similar circumstances.
I also want you to consider this, Please share your story with the world, whilst I appreciate that many of you feel this is private and aren’t comfortable in doing so, the more of us that do speak out and the more stories that get told, not only will people start to understand exactly what these companies and doctors have done they will start to generate an opinion on this as well. I completely understand if you choose not to do this, but please I do ask that you then actively participate in the sharing of other people’s stories, tell your family and friends what you have learnt and again this will help to spread more information about what is going on to real human beings, not some fictional characters in an imaginary story.
My next point is simple but many of us find it difficult, Don’t be afraid to ask questions and if you are not satisfied with the answers, seek the truth elsewhere! For many of us it is not in our nature to question what we are told, especially if the answer is coming from someone who we have been conditioned to believe is more knowledgeable than we are.
I urge you to break with your own ‘urge to believe’ especially if you aren’t 100% sure of what you have been told!
It wasn’t that long ago that MOM hip replacements were being ‘sold’ as the latest and greatest technology, long lasting and better wearing than all previous incarnations of a hip replacement and ideal if you wanted to retain an active lifestyle! I believed it and I now refer you back to the picture at the top of this article!
I also remember the head of the Australian Orthopaedic Association going on television and stating that the ‘cobalt issue’ is just media hype and driven by a few disgruntled patients! I refer you to the photograph of my leg!
Please take this point into consideration whenever you are speaking with anyone about YOUR HEALTH AND WELL BEING!
Finally, I invite each and every one of you to: Join the fight! We have each had our health (mental and physical) and our lives in general utterly devastated in some or many ways by the deceitful, unethical and greedy actions of a number of medical companies and unfortunately in some cases by the doctors who support them! I am not asking you to become a card carrying, flag waving true believer in the cause, but I am asking you to be a voice to be heard or another person willing to stand up and say I won’t let this happen to anyone else while I have a say!
If we are all able to unite against the Johnson and Johnson/De Puy’s, Smith and Nephew’s, Stryker’s and any other manufacturer and distributor of MOM technology in this world, we can make a difference. Remember, the one thing they will notice is a drop in profits! Even if you don’t want to speak up, we are all consumers at the end of the day, find out what other products these companies produce or own the rights to and simply choose not to purchase them! Again share this with those around you and see if they too will support us in this way!
This is not an idealistic waste of time but it certainly is a tactic in what will be a long battle. I assure you they will notice if the ‘bottom line’ is affected negatively! I hope by now you don’t think that I am just an angry, bitter person, because I generally am not, and those that truly know me will attest to this. However, those same people will also tell you I am a fiercely protective of those I care about and that now includes everyone who has been adversely affected by this terrible situation, as I do consider us all now as brothers and sisters in a grave injustice.
I am so grateful to have met people like those mentioned above because without learning their stories and re-living their experiences I would not have a true understanding of my own experiences, especially as we are spread all around the world and that can seem like a large gap to bridge. Thankfully we have this site and the ability to communicate with each other, so again I implore you, share your stories, speak up if you feel you can, listen to what others have to say and as I can’t reinforce enough seek the answers to ANY questions you might have! I hope to speak to you all again soon, feel free to contact me via the website and I hope that if even a few of you can join us and share your story we will all be more knowledgeable about those experiences and with knowledge comes power!
Stuart Cain
Related articles
- Stryker Rejuvenate Modular & ABG II Modular-Neck Hip Complications (earlsview.com)
- Early Clinical Failure of the Birmingham Metal-on-metal Hip Resurfacing Is Associated With Metalosis and Soft Tissue Necrosis (earlsview.com)
- Fosamax Caused Femur Fracture in Both Thighs, According to Maryland Woman’s Lawsuit (prweb.com)
- After Suffering Two Femur Fractures While Taking Fosamax, Indiana Woman Files Lawsuit Alleging Fosamax Caused Both Bone Breaks (prweb.com)
- Smith & Nephew Birmingham hip resurfacing – THE PREVALENCE OF FAILURE (earlsview.com)
- ‘Toxic’ hip replacement fears – Health – Belfast Newsletter (earlsview.com)
- Australia – Stuart Cain DePuy Tragedy Continues… (earlsview.com)
- Mississippi Woman Suffers from Femur Fracture after Taking Fosamax and Files Lawsuit Alleging Merck’s Bone Loss Drug Caused the Thigh Break (prweb.com)
- I’d suggest Stryker Hip Replacements (bnt.typepad.com)
- Smith & Nephew BHR – A benign psoas mass following metal-on-metal resurfacing of the hip (earlsview.com)
All the best Stuart…I’ll be thinking of you on the next phase of your marathon!! Thanks for sharing your story…it’s important for people to know what you are going through…I admire your courage and spirit in facing such a difficult situation.
Jan (Thornley)
Hi Jan,
Thanks for the kind wishes, my apologies if you had tried to contact me as I haven’t been at work since Feb and therefore didn’t have access to that email. I hope you have been doing well and didn’t get any more surprises! We are all involved in this in some way and as you will see over the coming days/weeks/months the situation, as I am sure all of the Smith and Nephew patients can now finally agree, is only going to get more intense and more public! Take care and I will keep you informed and thanks again for your kind wishes! Stuart Cain
“For the first time in a few surgeries now, I have an instinctual feeling of concern bordering on dread, now I am not usually a negative person, however I can’t escape my own doubts this time and I will just have to learn to deal with this”.
Without doubt that is the crux of the matter, or it is at least a very similar thought process for me, Stuart, and I’m only looking at a second hip revision (from a S&N modular head Mom prosthetic. I too have such thoughts, thoughts that appear all too frequently these past few months since the Aprli revision from the metalosis/AVAL/necrotic nightmare, of course like yours but not to such a severe extent. Such thoughts can no longer be entertained by my mind — not only because they are not at all entertaining but have the exact opposite effect for me. \
Only since I came here, and met other people mired in this bog as am I, have I learned to ‘change the channel’, so to speak. I mean, of course, ‘turning a deaf ear’ to that incessant voice in my head. A voice that is not necessarily the truth, worsens my situation and deppens the ‘hole’ I fell into a few moths ago. I thought “why in God’s name would I pour gasoline on the fire that rages already in my life”. A fire that has nearly consumed me, simply because it’s wearing me down after all of these years (I am also on my third knee on the opposite side, so in that respect, Stuart, we’re tied right now at three revisions each — though you’ll of course soon take the lead. You’ll do that in more ways than the one, as you’ll be able to speak of the horrors of the crucible your life has become, and warn others about the dangers inherent in your experiences (nowyou know, now we/they hear; now we are finally warned).
Those experiences are the only verifiable truth to me now, so the thinking — OK, the depression — has to be placed on the back burner for me, as hard as it is. I once heard a therapist say that mental problems were really just a human being listening far to intently to their continuous stream of negative inner thoughts, giving such thoughts too much heed. If I pay attention to the ‘doomsday’ machine inside of me that is activated at times, it starts to elevate, and I know now that my healing process is slowed and inhibited from my experiences, a place of truth that I can speak with some authority from. If I fixate on how evil S&N are I can start boiling, or I dwell on the prevarication and outright lying my surgeon and his hospital have done (and continue) to subject me too. I have recently quit drinking, and my adult son is showing up like my coach, trying to a get my quadricep to ‘fire’, working on my ‘core’, as the physical therapists might say. It hurts to do it, but even if a revision is looming, I’ll try and harden my body and steel myself for it. (I know you haven’t had that option, being relegated to that recliner chair).
Hearing from so many others, and especially talking (virtually) with the few people I know well here has been of immeasurable assistance to me. Were it not for Earl,the car might already by at the bottom of the cliff, and here I at least speak figuratively (though in total honesty, I have thought of my own mortality more than once through this trial of blood and tears).
But we are still alive, as the founder of the blog reminds me from time to time, and he reminds me that’s better than dead. Pain is life right now for me, and though it’s not much of a life at present — hobbled, housebound and harried — I feel for the first time that I can make the comeback I decide I’m going to make. Maybe I intended to say “whatever happens to me is going to happen, and I have to have the courage to stand as strong as I can and not let it kill me”. I say this because at fifty-nine I’m getting to the point where it’s hard to come out of a full-fledged nose-dive.
But please know that as your ‘hip’ friend (I’m both!), beset by very similar problems, yet on opposite sides of the globe, I am aware of what you’re going through, and will be aware of it the day you have surgery, and will be thinking about you during your tough time. And you will emerge from the fire wearing your scars, going forward into the fucking fray! (Can I say that here, Earl)? At times it just seems the best possible adjective, but I only go with it when it jumps off of these keys before I can stop it!
I will be sending you the best vibes I can emanate, Stuart, and always remember:
Illegitimi non carborundum!
You’ll come through this, oh hip brother of mine. (I say we can use both definitions of the word, when they apply like they do with most of us around here).
Love it! Great phraseology and great advice and determination.
No one is going to rob you of life!
Earl
Earl and Brooks,
What more can I say, another beautiful weekend here in ‘sunny’ Queensland and stuck in a chair with a fan on me!! However, as we all know, the war isn’t won with one battle!! We will get these bastards, and I know we can! Talk to you both again soon! Your hip brother!
Stu
Great day and my revised hip is hitting well at the driving range. The left hip is a sack of sh…t. Lol death to all pain! Won’t stop us!
And even simple things like the good weather can help us out, Stuart, you may end up wearing your swim trunks in that chair by summer, and if the one fan proves inadequate, you’ll simply have to get more of them. For me, it seems better to be warm than cold at revision time. (It was around 27 degrees Celsius here yesterday, and that is unbelievable for this time of year, and such sunny weather helps pick me up some (the only thing is that in another week or two that Big Weatherman in the sky will flip the weather switch to the ‘Cold’ position). That’s the hardest time of year for me, due to the increased pain cold weather brings to all of my major joints, and the endless gray rainclouds (which can induce ‘gray’ thoughts). But living in the very wet ‘terrarium’ that is the Pacific Northwest helps raise all of these giant plants. It’s what creates the 60 meter firs that cover the mountainsides. I love to camp amongst them a lot, but haven’t been able to get out in the woods and into the wilds of Nature for some time, but I know will again.
One of your major points — and it’s really almost thematic at Earl’s Place — is that we all are in this thing together, we all understand what we are all going through, and therefore relate to one another and can offer some degree of support. This cannot be understood by any person who hasn’t had the metal poisoning, complications revisions and unbelievable pain nearly all who visit here have. I have found that my wife perhaps understands least, and though she stands behind me in all of this she lately does not want to hear about how much pain I’m in. It creates ‘spousal’ tension (which can lead to serious strains in a marriage, even with someone who’s been with you for over three decades). That’s another thing these damn device makers are not aware of, how this can decimate a family. Even if they knew, it wouldn’t matter to them as much as their quarterly profits. In fact, WE don’t matter to them in the slightest, as Howard has so aptly pointed out here on more than one occasion.
When I first came to Earl’s View (a view most of us share!), I though it was mostly hip headlines and publications and/or studies. I didn’t think we could talk about all of the other attendant emotional and mental crap that rides alongside the physical we’re enduring. Depression over all of this can become as bad — sometimes worse — than the physical pain itself, or rather it becomes a source of pain in and of itself. For me, I have to have some kind of trigger mechanism that extinguishes any internal fires that might otherwise rage in me, putting them out before they begin (both Earl and Howard have helped me with this). This is a place where I can talk about all of the ramifications of this ordeal, things that I once had to keep to myself but need to see the light of day, where they can be ‘disinfected’.
As usual, I have written well enough in a ‘reply box’, so I’ll ‘hang up’ now. But we will always stand together in this thing, Suart — always. I’ll be thinking about you this month (what’s the revision date again, around October 17)? Just go get ’em man, be fearless like Earl, and you’ll get through the damn thing!
Brooks and Stuart,
I’ve had 4 hip ops . . . Smith and Nephew. My lawyer was doing a Multi-District-Litigation, yet now the other firm has dropped out. He says he only has one other client and it’s not looking well. Yes, I am quite outraged. But anger breeds suffering. Go to http://HarknessBallet.wordpress.com to see contact info. for Joseph Lyon, Attorney . . . we need more bros and sis’s to contact him. Also, other firms could contact him.
I was pretty sickened at watching the video, because that is just what happened to me: it all came out in a spurt, without infection.
May I put your blog entries on my blog for Harkness Ballet (thousands of dancers and companies have seen it, and dancers get hip and knee replacements . . . that’s the territory)?
Hi
Clearly there are more S&N problems out there than they admit to. Sorry to hear about your experiences and agony.
Feel free to re-post whatever you want.
I am happy to post your story too if you’d like me to?
Earl
Earl,
Yes, please do post the few hip posts I did recently . . .like you said, we’ve got to get together. More strength in numbers. http://HarknessBallet.wordpress.com
good wishes, well-being,
mickey
Pingback: It isn’t just MoM prosthesis that’s a problem… Paul’s story « Earl's View
Does anyone have any news of Stuart. Not sure how to find out if he is OK. I am really worried as he sounded so down in his last article. Since all this Debacle started for me in November I have had multiple problems – no doubt brought on by stress, the least of which is the battle to get money out of Depuy. They query every single thing, do they really think I WANT to go to physio every week, do they really think I just love having a walking stick and can only hobble. Do they think I can bend down and clean floors and cupboards. It just all makes me so angry. Guess I better go and do something destructive before I get any more worked up.
Hi Katherine
I will ring and see what the story is.
Yes it is stress that gets you in the end.
Earl
Pingback: Stuart Cain – Sage Advice – Things that every patient should consider before they look at compensation for a dodgy hip! « Earl's View